Which statement about promotion evaluation board scoring is false?

Which statement about promotion evaluation board scoring is false?

• A. Panel members score individual records via regular ballot after open discussion.
• B. Scores are compiled by the chair without discussion.
• C. The process includes a moderator and a rubric.
• D. Panel members score individual records exclusively by a closed ballot.

Answer: (A)

Understanding how a promotion evaluation board scores helps ensure fair, consistent judgments. In this process, a moderator guides the discussion and a rubric provides the criteria for scoring. Each panel member evaluates an individual’s record using a closed ballot, ensuring each member’s judgment remains independent and not swayed by others during the scoring itself. After all ballots are cast, the chair compiles the scores, and this tallying happens without further discussion to preserve objectivity. The statement describing scoring via a regular ballot after open discussion isn’t consistent with that approach, so it’s the one that’s false. The other points align with the process: there is a moderator and a rubric; scoring is done by a closed ballot; and the chair compiles scores without additional discussion.

Understanding how a promotion evaluation board scores helps ensure fair, consistent judgments. In this process, a moderator guides the discussion and a rubric provides the criteria for scoring. Each panel member evaluates an individual’s record using a closed ballot, ensuring each member’s judgment remains independent and not swayed by others during the scoring itself. After all ballots are cast, the chair compiles the scores, and this tallying happens without further discussion to preserve objectivity.

The statement describing scoring via a regular ballot after open discussion isn’t consistent with that approach, so it’s the one that’s false. The other points align with the process: there is a moderator and a rubric; scoring is done by a closed ballot; and the chair compiles scores without additional discussion.